Paycom Performance Management Logo
Paycom Performance Management Logo
Paycom

Paycom Performance Management

Composite Score
8.0 /10
CX Score
8.3 /10
Category
Paycom Performance Management
8.0 /10

What is Paycom Performance Management?

Paycom Performance Management offers complete employee assessments with performance review software for consistency, efficiency and less burden. Their HR performance management software houses all the documentation, resources and processes you need to offer a consistent system for evaluation.

Company Details


Need Assistance?

We're here to help you with understanding our reports and the data inside to help you make decisions.

Get Assistance

Paycom Performance Management Ratings

Real user data aggregated to summarize the product performance and customer experience.

Product scores listed below represent current data. This may be different from data contained in reports and awards, which express data as of their publication date.

89 Likeliness to Recommend

100 Plan to Renew

91 Satisfaction of Cost Relative to Value


{y}
{name}

Emotional Footprint Overview

Product scores listed below represent current data. This may be different from data contained in reports and awards, which express data as of their publication date.

+95 Net Emotional Footprint

The emotional sentiment held by end users of the software based on their experience with the vendor. Responses are captured on an eight-point scale.

How much do users love Paycom Performance Management?

0% Negative
0% Neutral
100% Positive

Pros

  • Helps Innovate
  • Continually Improving Product
  • Reliable
  • Enables Productivity

Feature Ratings

Average 87

Check-Ins/1-on-1s

96

Goal Setting and Tracking (Goal Management)

91

Integration Capabilities

91

Employee Recognition

87

Performance Reviews

87

Employee Engagement

87

Dashboard

86

Feedback Models

82

Reporting and Analytics

82

Development Planning

80

Vendor Capability Ratings

Average 92

Breadth of Features

100

Usability and Intuitiveness

96

Quality of Features

96

Business Value Created

96

Ease of Customization

92

Vendor Support

92

Product Strategy and Rate of Improvement

92

Availability and Quality of Training

91

Ease of IT Administration

91

Ease of Implementation

86

Ease of Data Integration

86

Paycom Performance Management Reviews

Camilla S.

  • Role: Human Resources
  • Industry: Other
  • Involvement: End User of Application
Validated Review
Verified Reviewer

Submitted Aug 2025

Reviews and Comp Speak the Same Language

Likeliness to Recommend

8 /10

What differentiates Paycom Performance Management from other similar products?

We needed a system where comp, goals, and feedback lived together. Paycom’s integration with payroll let us build performance review cycles that auto-linked to raise cycles. That level of connectivity helped remove manager guesswork and biased raises

What is your favorite aspect of this product?

The performance journal tool is surprisingly effective. We trained managers to log weekly notes there. So when review season hits, they pull full context—not just memories from the last two weeks. It made feedback less emotional, more actionable

What do you dislike most about this product?

It’s not built for agile cycles. We work in sprints and project-based staffing, but Paycom’s cycles feel very quarterly or semi-annual

What recommendations would you give to someone considering this product?

If you’re already using Paycom for payroll and comp, this ties in neatly. But don’t force it into a culture that thrives on casual feedback loops. Build those elsewhere. Use Paycom to formalize reviews tied to pay decisions

Pros

  • Reliable
  • Effective Service
  • Client Friendly Policies
  • Transparent

Correy D.

  • Role: Human Resources
  • Industry: Other
  • Involvement: End User of Application
Validated Review
Verified Reviewer

Submitted Jul 2025

Turning SharePoint into a Living HR Playbook

Likeliness to Recommend

9 /10

What differentiates Paycom Performance Management from other similar products?

At our agency, quarterly goal-setting is brutal — tied to campaign KPIs, not just personal growth. Paycom’s cascading goals and weighted scoring align well with that style of performance culture

What is your favorite aspect of this product?

We’ve built different sets for client-facing, tech, and strategy roles. The system forces managers to tie each rating to actual deliverables, which has helped reduce inflated reviews. Also, its post-review action plan workflow closes the loop better than most tools we’ve tried.

What do you dislike most about this product?

We often have team leads, client partners, and directors weighing in on the same person, and stitching that together manually gets messy. Also, the calibration tools feel basic — hard to detect scoring drift unless you export to Excel.

What recommendations would you give to someone considering this product?

If your agency has scorecard-driven culture like ours, Paycom enforces standardisation better than Google Forms or ad hoc review docs. But pair it with a strong coaching culture. Otherwise, the feedback risks becoming too compliance-driven. Build templates based on campaign lifecycle

Pros

  • Helps Innovate
  • Continually Improving Product
  • Reliable
  • Efficient Service

Karl J.

  • Role: Human Resources
  • Industry: Other
  • Involvement: End User of Application
Validated Review
Verified Reviewer

Submitted Feb 2025

HR’s Hidden Weapon

Likeliness to Recommend

9 /10

What differentiates Paycom Performance Management from other similar products?

Paycom encourages ongoing feedback and goal-setting. For a talent manager, that’s essential in creating a culture of continuous improvement rather than just annual reviews

What is your favorite aspect of this product?

Instead of waiting for formal reviews, managers and employees can exchange feedback instantly. That means performance discussions aren’t just a once-a-year event—they happen as things unfold, which helps with engagement and development.

What do you dislike most about this product?

Customizing reports sometimes feels like wrestling with an outdated dashboard, and I wish the analytics were more visual and intuitive

What recommendations would you give to someone considering this product?

If your company takes employee growth seriously and wants to move beyond traditional performance reviews, this tool is a great fit.

Pros

  • Enables Productivity
  • Inspires Innovation
  • Caring
  • Fair